.png)
In the realm of education, leadership often feels like a relentless balancing act—an unending orchestration of expectations, decisions, and scrutiny from every angle. As school leaders, we step into our roles brimming with passion and a vision for what education can be, only to find ourselves lost in the whirlwind of compliance, metrics, and demands. If you’ve ever felt the weight of this burden, you’re not alone.
Losing My Way
When we enter the world of education, it's often with a burning desire to witness transformation—those “aha” moments when students light up with understanding. Yet, over time, external pressures can dim that fire. Bureaucracy, standardized tests, micromanagement, and the sheer volume of tasks can leave even the most passionate educators feeling disconnected from their purpose.
There I was on my way out the door during dismissal, talking to member of my staff when I heard something that rocked me - a teacher’s simple comment—“I like seeing this principal back.” I began my school leadership journey with a commitment to doing what I could to build community and joy. Somehow, this commitment got buried under the demands and expectations that come with the position. It brought to light how easily the grind can overshadow the joy and relational essence of leadership. It was a wake-up call: leadership must be rooted in authentic connection, not just task management. With the demands of the position, you must be vigilant. Part of the reason this is such an issue comes from our understanding of the challenges we face.
The Misdiagnosis of Challenges
A core tension in education lies in differentiating between technical and adaptive challenges.
Technical Challenges are straightforward problems with clear solutions—like fixing a brake pad.
Adaptive Challenges, however, require a change in beliefs, behaviors, and culture. These are deeply human issues, resistant to quick fixes.
For instance, asking teachers to adopt new strategies or standards isn’t just about providing training or resources. It demands a shift in mindset—a relinquishing of old habits for the sake of growth. And that’s where the difficulty lies. Leaders often feel pressured to solve adaptive problems with technical tools, resulting in frustration and burnout for all parties involved.
Adaptive leadership requires a mindset shift—from quick fixes to deep, transformative work.
For adaptive leaders, those who are grounded in authenticity and committed to justice, this shift begins with embracing five essential pillars: Community, Critics, Counting the Cost, Casualties, and Complicity.
1. Community: Build It, Don’t Just Expect It
Best Practice: Community isn’t built by chance; it’s cultivated intentionally. It begins with creating a shared vision and fostering trust among all stakeholders. This means consistently making space for others’ voices, acknowledging collective struggles, and celebrating small victories together.
Practice Radical Empathy: Take time to understand the individual and collective needs of your team. This could look like regular check-ins where you ask open-ended questions, such as, What’s one thing I can do to better support you this week?
Be Visible and Relatable: As a leader, your presence matters. Whether it’s showing up in the hallway, participating in a classroom activity, or joining staff during their potluck, these moments signal that you are not above the team—you are part of it.
Create Psychological Safety: Community thrives where people feel safe to share concerns without fear of judgment. Model vulnerability by sharing your own challenges and growth areas, and invite others to do the same.
Key Reminder: Community requires moving from transactional relationships to transformational ones where everyone is invested in shared outcomes.
Community happens when my problem becomes our problem.
2. Critics: Turn Them Into Coaches
Critics are often the overlooked goldmine of leadership. While their dissent can feel exhausting, their resistance often holds the key to refining your vision. Critics challenge us to interrogate our assumptions and sharpen our strategies.
Seek to Understand, Not Defend: When met with opposition, resist the urge to argue. Instead, ask critics thoughtful questions like, What would you do differently? or What about this plan feels difficult or ineffective?
Involve Them Early: Often, resistance stems from feeling excluded or unheard. Include dissenting voices in decision-making processes early, allowing them to shape the direction instead of reacting to it.
Establish Clear Norms for Dialogue: Criticism without constructive purpose can derail progress. Set ground rules for dialogue that emphasize respect, listening, and solution-oriented feedback.
Key Reminder: Critics aren’t enemies—they’re collaborators in disguise. Their perspectives might highlight blind spots you wouldn’t see otherwise, helping you strengthen your leadership.
3. Count the Cost: Understand the Depth of Change
Adaptive leadership is expensive—emotionally, relationally, and professionally. True transformation demands that people relinquish something: a belief, a habit, or a comfort. As leaders, we must not only anticipate these costs but name them, honor them, and guide our teams through the discomfort of change.
Anticipate Resistance: Identify what people will have to leave behind to embrace the change. For example, will teachers need to abandon long-standing but outdated instructional practices? Will staff need to adjust to new accountability measures?
Communicate the Why: People are more willing to endure discomfort when they understand the bigger picture. Share the vision behind the change and connect it to their personal and professional values.
Support Through Transition: Provide practical tools, time, and space for people to adapt. If you’re introducing a new grading policy, for instance, offer workshops, one-on-one coaching, or collaborative planning sessions.
Key Reminder: Adaptive leadership demands that we name the losses people will experience and acknowledge the emotional labor of change. Without this, we risk alienating those we hope to lead.
4. Casualties: Not Everyone Will Come Along
One of the hardest truths of leadership is that not everyone will make the journey. This is especially true with adaptive change, where the discomfort of the unfamiliar can lead some to disengage entirely.
Decide What You Can—and Cannot—Control: Some resistance is situational and can be addressed with support. However, some individuals may choose to cling to the status quo. Recognize the difference and focus your energy on those willing to grow.
Set Boundaries With Detractors: Establish clear boundaries if certain individuals consistently undermine progress. For example, limit unproductive interactions or assign these individuals tasks that align with their strengths but keep them from hindering others.
Celebrate Those Who Stay: Losing team members can feel like a failure, but it often clears the way for others to step up. Acknowledge and affirm the commitment of those who remain invested in the vision.
Key Reminder: Casualties are inevitable, but how you navigate them will define the integrity and resilience of your leadership. Letting go of those who resist change sends a clear message about your commitment to progress.
5. Complicity: Own Your Part of the Problem
Perhaps the most difficult of the five C’s is confronting your own role in the challenges your team or school faces. Leadership isn’t about pointing fingers; it’s about picking up the mirror and saying, Here’s how I contributed to this mess, and here’s how I’m working to fix it.
Engage in Reflective Practice: Regularly ask yourself, " What behaviors have I modeled that might perpetuate this issue? or What have I avoided addressing because it felt too difficult?
Invite Feedback: Create structured opportunities for your team to give you honest feedback. Tools like anonymous surveys or facilitated listening sessions can offer insights you might miss otherwise.
Model Accountability: When you’ve made a mistake or fallen short, own it publicly. For example, if a new initiative has caused confusion, acknowledge where you might have failed to communicate effectively and commit to improving.
Key Reminder: Complicity is not a mark of failure but a call to action. When you own your part, you empower others to do the same, creating a culture of mutual accountability and growth.
Bringing It All Together
The five C’s are not a checklist—they are a way of being. Adaptive leadership demands that we embrace the messy, human realities of change while staying grounded in our values and vision. For you, the leader, this means showing up with courage, vulnerability, and an unwavering commitment to growth—not just for your team, but for yourself.
When practiced together, the five C’s create a powerful framework for transformation:
Community reminds us that leadership is a shared effort.
Critics challenge us to refine our approach.
Counting the Cost ensures we respect the labor of change.
Casualties free us to focus on those who are ready to move forward.
Complicity keeps us humble and accountable.
In education, we often look outward for solutions, but true progress comes when we start within.
Reclaiming Joy in Leadership
Leadership is demanding, but it doesn’t have to mean sacrificing joy. Reclaiming joy starts with aligning your values and behaviors, bridging the gap between who you want to be and how you lead.
This meant recognizing when cynicism and sarcasm crept into my demeanor, diminishing the positivity I sought to model. It meant being honest about my shortcomings and publicly committing to do better—not just for myself but those I serve.
A Call to Reflect and Act
Adaptive leadership isn’t about quick fixes. It’s about doing the deep, often uncomfortable work of reflection and growth. It’s about embracing the silent screams of frustration and transforming them into voices of purpose, accountability, and resilience.
As you navigate your leadership journey, I invite you to ask:
How can you build community within your school?
Are you willing to listen to your critics?
Have you counted the cost of the changes you’re asking for?
Can you accept the inevitability of casualties for the sake of progress?
Most importantly, are you ready to own your complicity and take responsibility for the mess, even as you celebrate the magic?
Our schools deserve leaders who are willing to grapple with these questions. Transactional leadership may check boxes but does little to sustain the adjustments needed for those we serve. Your ability to embrace adaptive leadership may be the difference in generational futures in countless families.
Comments